Who Gets Hurt Most in a Divorce? Surprising Truths About Divorce Outcomes

Rajiv Thackeray 0 Comments 5 July 2025

No one stands at the altar picturing solicitor fees, single beds, and spreadsheeting every last pan. Still, here we are. When I think back to my mate's split last winter, it wasn't the storybook scene you see in movies. He slept on a mate’s sofa eating takeaway, while she managed three kids under seven and their endless school stuff. The real question wasn’t how they broke up – it was, ‘Who actually comes out worst?’

The Financial Fallout: Who Pays the Biggest Price?

If you ask anyone what hurts most in a divorce, money gets mentioned before feelings, every single time. In Australia, the average cost of a divorce is around $20,000–$30,000 per couple, with Sydney easily topping that, according to the Australian Institute of Family Studies’ most recent numbers. Now, those legal bills are only a slice of the pain. When you split assets, your actual net worth isn’t just cut in half – it usually dips well below that once you add taxes, moving costs, and the infamous lawyer fees. For instance, research from AMP and NATSEM has found divorced people retire with about 25% less superannuation than those who stay married. So, if you were hoping to finally buy that campervan once the dust settles, you might be driving a second-hand hatchback instead.

Now, let’s talk gender. There’s this unlucky trend where women—particularly if they’ve taken time out to raise kids—end up statistically worse off in financial terms. A 2024 report from the Workplace Gender Equality Agency shows that single mothers in Australia are almost twice as likely to experience ‘financial hardship’ after a split compared to dads, even when you factor in child support. Yes, shared custody helps, but mums are more likely to be in part-time or lower-paid jobs post-divorce, which affects their income and retirement savings. On the flip side, men do tend to bounce back financially a bit faster on average, but this mostly applies to blokes without primary custody of kids. The emotional toll can mean extra spending anyway—think retail therapy, new gadgets, or suddenly upgrading your car.

AspectMen After DivorceWomen After Divorce
Change in Net Worth *-23% avg.-29% avg.
Chance of Financial Hardship **16%31%
Superannuation Gap (retirement funds) ***Down 15%Down 27%
  • * AMP & NATSEM Divorce Study 2023
  • ** ABS Household Financial Wellbeing Snapshot 2024
  • *** Workplace Gender Equality Agency, 2024

Property is another headache. Sydney’s median house price in 2025 is well over $1.3 million, and not many couples have piles of cash stashed under the bed. Usually, the family home gets sold (sometimes below market in a rush), and both parties end up renting much smaller places or moving to more affordable suburbs. That move alone triggers school changes, longer commutes, and social disruption—costs no spreadsheet can sum up.

Emotional Toll: Who Feels It Hardest?

Sure, money stings, but the mental punch of divorce is a totally different animal. For most people, the early months are a cocktail of panic, grief, relief, and total confusion—even if you’re the one making the call. Recent numbers from Relationships Australia reveal that almost 60% of people say their mental health takes a dive during the first year of divorce. You see the impact in everything: blokes drop weight or get insomnia, women talk about feeling burned out and unsupported, and both deal with waves of guilt.

The myth of ‘winning’ or ‘losing’ emotionally is a trickier beast. Some blokes get hit by loneliness, especially if mates take sides or their routine revolved around family life. Men are statistically less likely to have a strong emotional support network after separation, according to a 2024 VicHealth study. That’s probably why anxiety, depression, and even substance abuse spike in the months after a split. It’s rough but not hopeless: evidence shows men who reach out for support—even just regular chats with mates—are far more likely to recover their mental health within a year.

For women, especially those juggling young kids, the story is more about burnout and emotional exhaustion. You have the pressure of solo parenting, career setbacks if you missed years in the workforce, and often a nagging sense that ‘everyone else is moving on except me.’ Therapy services see a big jump in female patients post-divorce, and not just for depression; anxiety, panic attacks, and stress-related health issues are common too.

So, is it possible to come out stronger post-divorce? There's no miracle cure, but it turns out routine helps. Sydney psychologist Dr. Helen Flanders recommends anyone going through a split structure their days. “Meet people, eat proper meals, and get outside—you can’t sort out everything at once. Little wins beat big, unfocused efforts.” Feels like basic advice, but it works: people who focus on daily stability, rather than obsessing over what-if’s, report bouncing back twice as fast.

The Kids’ Perspective: Silent Losers or Strong Survivors?

The Kids’ Perspective: Silent Losers or Strong Survivors?

If you’ve ever sat through a custody negotiation—or just seen the look on a kid’s face when you break the news—you’ll know children aren’t immune to divorce fallout. The Australian Child Wellbeing Project found that 1 in 3 Aussie kids report feeling ‘less secure’ after their parents separate, especially if custody is messy or communication breaks down. That said, kids are not doomed—how parents handle the process makes all the difference.

It’s tempting to believe disrupting the family means your child is scarred for life. The reality’s more nuanced. If parents stay civil and keep routines predictable, children can actually emerge more resilient, learning key life skills like negotiation, compromise, and self-advocacy. When things get ugly—silent treatment, badmouthing, or using kids as messengers—the risks spike. Kids from high-conflict divorces are three times more likely to struggle with schoolwork, friendships and anxiety, according to the 2023 Monash University Families Research Study.

Age matters too. Little kids (under 6) crave routine and face attachment issues if both parents disappear for long stretches. Older children are more prone to ‘parentification’—basically taking on adult worries before they’re ready. Teenagers may rebel or isolate, believing they have to pick a side. The worst outcomes tend to happen when adults ‘overshare’ grown-up problems and treat kids like sounding boards. If you let them just be kids and focus on everyday stuff, the fallout is far milder.

Tactics that actually help: prioritise shared custody if safe and possible (kids do best seeing both parents regularly), agree on school schedules early so kids know what to expect, and communicate logistics in writing to avoid mix-ups. Sydney family lawyer Mia Brandt also suggests parents avoid sudden big changes—like moving suburbs or switching schools—without weeks of prep. “Even if you’re desperate to start over, kids need stability. Too much change at once wrecks their trust.”

How to Come Out Fairer: Real Tips for Easing the Blow

No one walks away completely unscathed by divorce, but not everyone gets devastated. There are real ways to limit how much you lose—financially, emotionally, or with your kids. Here’s what you can actually do:

  • Don’t DIY Your Finances: Get a financial adviser before the split, if possible. Knowing the true value of assets and debts (not just ballpark numbers) can be worth thousands. Missing superannuation or under-valuing property leaves too many people in the lurch.
  • Handle Your Papers Like a Pro: Make copies of every single important document: payslips, tax returns, loan statements, super info. Having this stuff can mean the difference between a fair share and a messy court fight.
  • Pick Your Fights: No one wins every battle. Decide what really matters—school catchment, the family dog, who gets the camping gear—and let go of the rest. Court battles rarely end well for anyone, and the fees chew up assets fast.
  • Shield the Kids: If arguments get heated, keep them offline and out of earshot. Set routines, let kids keep up with mates and school, and help them talk through worries with a counsellor if needed.
  • Use the Experts: If emotional stress gets overwhelming, a few sessions with a therapist or support group (even Zoom chats) can speed up recovery. For legal stuff, even one meeting with a lawyer can stop huge mistakes.
  • Start a New Routine: It’s tempting to hibernate or over-socialise, but a steady routine (work, gym, dinner, seeing mates) is gold. It restores some order and gives you a new story to tell about yourself, not just ‘divorced’.
  • Protect Your Digital Spaces: Reset passwords, update bank logins, and secure your key accounts. It’s boring but avoids nasty surprises later.

No matter where you stand, there’s no ‘winner’ in divorce—just different losses. But with smart moves, you can protect your future, keep your sanity, and build a new chapter that makes the pain worth it. You’re not defined by what you lose, but by how you bounce back.